"Where Movie Critics Get A Taste Of Their Own Medicine!"
Subscribe To Weekly Newsletter!

"I shudder to think what would happen if we locked horns more frequently." [comment after being selected as one of Critic Doctor's Top 10 Worst Critics of 2003]

Leonard Maltin, Hot Ticket TV

"I regularly enjoy and respect your work, particularly since you aim to hold us critics accountable for what we write. Whether you agree or disagree, it's a positive thing you're doing!"

Mark Sells, The Oregon Herald

"Since I write reviews mainly out of a love of film and a desire to express my opinion, it's gratifying to receive recognition. When that recognition comes from someone as respected as Herb Kane's The Critic Doctor, it is doubly appreciated." [comment after being selected as one of Critic Doctor's Top 10 Best Critics of 2003]

James Berardinelli, ReelViews.net

"Where the hip and flip rip crix for kicks. Proves once and for all that sadism can be funny." [From the print column "The 100 Coolest Film Sites on the Web" - Vol. VII No. 2]

FADE IN Magazine, Fadeinonline.com

"Well organized and visually appealing site takes an interesting approach to reviewing movies...clever twist on the traditional movie review turns the tables on movie critics."

Zap2it, Zap2it.com

"What a radical concept indeed! In short, CriticDoctor is a viable and resourceful venue where the critiquer can get their rightful dose of comeuppance in the form of healthy constructive criticism. It's official...the doctor is finally in!"

Frank Ochieng, Movie Eye

"It's actually a great thing that there's someone keeping tabs on us critics, since so many throw out scathing reviews and/or glorify those films that are way under par. I welcome your analysis of my reviews."

BeatBoxBetty (BeatBoxBetty.com)

"Just wanted to drop you a line to say my token "nice job" comment. I must say that it's a privilege to be raked over the coals by you on a semi-regular basis."

Michael Dequina (Film Threat & Mr. Brown's Movie Site)

"It's nice that someone is out there looking out for the little guy in making sure that critics are honest and truthful." [from Critic Doctor interview]

Anderson Jones (E! Online)

“I was grateful that SOMEONE out there had the intelligence to dissect, as nicely as you did, the dull-witted myopia of these negative reviews....Well done, and I think your site looks like a great and necessary corrective to a world increasingly filled with puffery and kneejerk bandwagon sloganeering posing as criticism.” [commenting on "Man On The Moon" review]

Owen Gleiberman (Entertainment Weekly)

"I really like this column. Very entertaining. Very smart."

Chris Gore (FilmThreat.com & former host of "The New Movie Show" - FX Channel)

“Intrigued.”

Roger Ebert (Chicago Sun-Times and "Ebert & Roeper and the Movies" - Buena Vista TV)

"When I checked out your site, I was expecting something mean-spirited and hostile to critics. Actually, it's both clever and intelligent."

Mike McGranaghan (The Aisle Seat)

“I checked out your web site and had a fine time reading your critiques. Reviewing the reviewers is a fine idea and I hope you stick to it.”

Ed Johnson-Ott, (NUVO Newsweekly)

“It makes me very happy to know you enjoy my reviews to such a degree..." [comment after being selected as one of Critic Doctor's Top 10 Best Critics of 2003]

Rob Blackwelder (splicedwire.com)

“I checked out your site and I like it. Keep up the good work of keeping us honest.”

John Decker, “Bolt Upright” – (johndecker.com)

“Thanks for including me in your list of ‘doctored’ critics! I enjoyed your site thoroughly, and will be returning in the future. Anybody who takes me to task is cool in my book.”

Chuck Rudolph (matineemag.com)

“I came across a review of mine being referenced in your ‘American Beauty’ piece and thought you might like to check out the site I write for. It may be suicidal to invite criticism, but what the hell - - I think your site has merit.”

Jeff “who writes under the pseudonym “vornporn” (aboutfilm.com)

“Neat site. I enjoy being in the minority opinion, too!"

Christopher Null (filmcritic.com)

“I certainly hope you will take shots at my reviews! I know I won’t be officially baptized into the world of criticism until I’m taken to the cleaners by the Critic Doctor!"...."Yours is a website that truly sparkles with wit and wry humor"...."You're quite skilled at poking fun in a manner that is neither hurtful nor mean-spirited."

Michael Brendan (maddogreviews.com)

“Thank you for your analysis of my UNBREAKABLE review. I'm in good company.”

Vladimir Lacas (kxnt.com)

“Thanks for the kind words, and also for a very interesting column. The new 'Grinch' is such a travesty; I can't believe how many people fell for it. You nailed it."

Stephanie Zacharek (salon.com)

“I am honored to be noted on critic doctor.”

Dave White (ifilm.com)

“Thanks. Uh, I think.”

Bob Butler (Kansas City Star)

“Thanks for nailing us...I really enjoy your site and am quite honored that you picked us.”

JoBlo (joblo.com)

“It's an honor to be included, sugarplums and all! My best wishes for the holidays, and I hope to appear on your site again in 2001." [commenting on "The Grinch" review]

Nell Minow (moviemom.com)

“I had a chance to look at your site this time and liked it.”

Susan Stark (Detroit News)

"Thanks for your kind words. Please do not fold, bend or otherwise mutilate your pea brain." [commenting on "3000 Miles to Graceland" review]

Peter Stack (San Francisco Chronicle)

"Thanks; it's a thrill to be evaluated by the Critic Doctor!"

Rod Armstrong, Editor-in-Chief (reel.com)

"Groovy site."

Carrey Rickey (Philidelphia Inquirer)